Toaster Oven Dishes, Pans and Accessories

This post may contain affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Disclosure.

A non-convection toaster oven is often used to reheat leftovers, and make toast or snacks. Convection toaster ovens can be used to prepare many meals and foods such as chicken, potatoes, bread, desserts, and pizza.

Regardless of the type of toaster oven you use, you’ll need cookware that is safe and fits in the oven. We have some ideas for quality toaster oven baking dishes, pans, and accessories.

Dishes

Le Creuset Stoneware Rectangular Dish

Le Creuset PG1047S-1867 Stoneware Rectangular Dish, 7 by 5-Inch, Cerise (Cherry Red)

This 7 x 5-inch Le Creuset baking dish is suitable for use in freezers, ovens, broilers, and microwaves. It is also dishwasher safe if you don't have time to handwash it.

When you are cooking, the food will be heated evenly throughout so you won't have to be concerned about the edges getting burned. Since this dish is made with dense stoneware there won't be any moisture ingress. This is beneficial because it it prevents rippling or cracking.   

The exterior is enameled so it will resist scratching and staining. The non-stick surface allows for foods to be easily released for serving.  

Color options: Cherry and Cobalt

Check Price at Amazon

Le Creuset Heritage Stoneware Oval Au Gratin Dish

Le Creuset PG0400-2067 Heritage Stoneware Oval Au Gratin Dish, 24-Ounce, Cerise

This Le Creuset Heritage Stoneware Oval Au Gratin Dish is high-quality stoneware with a capacity of 24 ounces. 

The stoneware has been fired to ensure it is as hardwearing as possible. This means it will not mark when utensils such as knives come into contact with it.

It can be safely used in microwave ovens, standard ovens and in broilers. It will allow for the even distribution of heat when items are cooking in it.

It is also suitable for use in freezers thanks to its high levels of thermal resistance and can be safely cleaned in dishwashers.

Its porosity is less than 1% meaning it will not be susceptible to moisture penetration causing issues such as rippling or cracking.

Note: We emailed Le Creuset asking for the dish dimensions. This article will be updated when the information is received. It takes some companies a few weeks to respond to emails these days.

As with all purchases, check to see if free returns are an option in case this does not fit inside your toaster oven.

Colors options:  Cerise, Flame,  Marseille, White, Marine

Check Price at Amazon

Bellemain Set of 6 Porcelain Ramekins

Bellemain Porcelain Ramekins, set of 6 (4 oz, white)

This set of six 4-oz Bellemain Porcelain Ramekins is ideal for serving a variety of foods and desserts. These include souffles, appetizers, sauces and dips.

These ramekins are made from glazed porcelain, which is thick enough to withstand temperature extremes,  so whether they are being heated in the microwave or frozen in the freezer, they'll cope with either.

This glazing also prevents any flavor or odor from being absorbed, nor will they absorb any toxins from cleaning products, for example. They will also resist scratches, cracks, and chips.

They come in an all-white color so they will look great on any table be that as individual servings or while being used as a set.

A larger 10-ounce size is available.

Check Price at Amazon

Bakeware

Chicago Metallic Non-Stick Toaster Oven Bakeware Set

Chicago Metallic 8044 Non-Stick Toaster Oven Bakeware Set, 4-Piece, Carbon Steel

This set of 4 Chicago Bakeware Set includes a baking pan, a 6-cup muffin pan, a cake/roasting pan, and a cooling rack. They are primarily suited for use in a toaster oven.

Each of the baking pans is constructed from high-quality carbon steel and can be used in oven temperatures up to 450°F.

They all feature silicone based non-stick coating which means anything baked or roasted on them should be easy to release and this also ensures that cleaning them is easy too.

They are dishwasher safe, although to prolong their life hand washing is preferable.

7-piece and 8-piece sets are also available.

Check Price at Amazon

Nordic Ware 3 Piece Naturals Compact Grill and Bake Set

Nordic Ware 43290 3 Piece Naturals Compact Grill and Bake Set, Silver

The Nordic Ware 3 Piece Grill and Bake Set comprises a broiling pan, a broiling rack, and a baking pan. They can be used to cook a variety of items such as sausages or steak with the broiler pan and bread or cakes in the baking pan.

All the items are made from aluminum and each of them has been coated with a special non-stick compound to ensure every item you cook is released without any difficulty.

Dishwashers are not recommended for cleaning them as this may damage the surface coating.

Check Price at Amazon

Toaster Oven Sheet Pans

Nordic Ware Natural Aluminum Commercial Baker's Quarter Sheet

Nordic Ware Natural Aluminum Commercial Baker's Quarter Sheet, 2-Pack

These two Nordic Ware baker's quarter sheets are made from 100% aluminum, meaning there is no risk whatsoever that they will rust during their entire lifetime.

The rims of the sheets are reinforced to prevent warping

They can be used to bake a variety of items especially those where multiple items are baked at once such as small cakes and buns.

Due to the heat conductivity properties of the aluminum, foods will be baked evenly throughout as the temperature distribution is conducted equitably across the sheets.

Cleaning should be done under hot running water and not in a dishwasher as this may damage the sheets.

Check Price at Amazon

Nordic Ware 47400 1/8 Sheet Pan

Nordic Ware 47400 1/8 Sheet Pan, One Size, Aluminum

For use in toaster ovens, this Nordic Ware 1/8 Sheet Pan is suitable for cooking a variety of foods. This includes meats such as burgers and most types of vegetables. It can also be used for savory or sweet foods too.

The sheet's dimensions are 10 inches by 7 inches by 1 inch deep, and it is constructed from aluminum.

One of the benefits of aluminum is that it has excellent heat conduction properties, and this allows foods in the sheet to cook evenly.  Aluminum will also not rust, thus prolonging the lifetime of the sheet.

When not being used for cooking the sheet is also suitable for use as a serving tray for snacks or sandwiches.

Check Price at Amazon

Accessories

Silpat Non-Stick Silicone Baking Mat

Silpat Non-Stick Silicone Baking Mat, Petite Jelly Roll Size, 8-1/4

This Silpat Silicone Baking Mat can be used in a number of ways thanks to its non-stick qualities.

The most popular is for it to line baking trays or roasting pans before adding the items you are about to cook. Its non-stick surface ensures that when you take them out of the oven, they can be released very easily, without having to use oils, sprays or grease beforehand.

Made from fiberglass mesh with a silicone coating, they are robust and as well as being oven safe, they can be used in the microwave, and they can be washed in the dishwasher.

When not being used they can be rolled up and easily stored away.

Check Price at Amazon

Kitchen + Home Toaster Oven Liner 

Kitchen + Home Toaster Oven Liner - Heavy Duty 100% PFOA & BPA Free – FDA Approved Non-stick Reusable Toaster Oven Liner - 2 Pack

This is a simple and easy-to-use toaster oven liner which is suitable for use on baking trays and roasting pans, especially in toaster ovens, however its main purpose is to line the oven base.

It can catch spills, drips and other food debris and thus help to keep your oven clean. By catching all of these there will be less need for you to scrape them off the surface of the bottom of your oven.

The material used for this oven liner is extremely durable and can withstand temperatures up to 500F. It has also been FDA approved.

Its original dimensions are 13 inches by 11 inches however it can be cut down to size in order to fit into smaller toaster ovens.

Check Price at Amazon

ThermoPro TP03 Digital Instant Read Meat Thermometer Kitchen  

ThermoPro TP03 Digital Instant Read Meat Thermometer Kitchen Cooking Food Candy Thermometer with Backlight and Magnet for Oil Deep Fry BBQ Grill Smoker Thermometer

This ThermoPro Digital Instant Read Meat Thermometer is powered by a AAA battery and is used to measure the temperature of food items, either when they are being cooked or before.

Its steel probe can be angled to suit, and it is pointed end is pushed into the food item being tested. It can read temperatures ranging from -58°F to 572°F.

When checking temperatures, the readout appears within 3 to 5 seconds on the small LCD display. This is backlit to make the readout even easier to see.

When not in use the probe can be folded away, and should the thermometer be on for 10 minutes or more without use, it will auto-shutoff to save the battery life.

Check Price at Amazon

ThermoPro TP20 Wireless Remote Digital Cooking Food Meat Thermometer 

ThermoPro TP-07 Wireless BBQ Meat Thermometer for Grilling Smoker Oven Kitchen Turkey Remote Digital Cooking Food Grill Thermometer with Probe, 300 Feet Range, Smart LCD Backlit Screen

This ThermoPro Meat Thermometer with Probe uses two probes which are connected by wire to a transmitter. This transmitter will display the temperature on its LCD display.

One of the benefits of the two probes is that you can measure temperatures in different ways. You use them both in one piece of meat for more accurate readings, have one in the meat and the other measuring the surrounding temperature, or you could simply measure two different pieces of meat

However, one of the best features of this digital food thermometer is that it can be used remotely. The system has a receiver and the reading from the transmitter can be sent to the receiver with a range of up to 300 feet.

This means you do not need to be sitting next to the meat in order to check its temperature and can instead sit with your guests.

Check Price at Amazon

Final Thoughts

If you have been wondering "Which baking dishes will fit in my toaster oven?" there are some great options available. Be sure to read the user manual to make sure the baking dish you are thinking about buying is made of a material that can be used in your toaster oven.

Another tip is to measure the interior of your toaster oven to make sure the dish you are planning to buy (include the handles) will fit.